%UXJVDQYLVQಣ %UXNVDQYLVQಣ 8VHU 0DQXDO LQJ LQJ .ºOH IU\VHಣ VNDE & ) & )/ )ULGJH )UHH]HU .
,11+2/' 6LNNHUKHWVLQIRUPDVMRQ 6LNNHUKHWVDQYLVQLQJHU 0RQWHULQJ %HWMHQLQJVSDQHO 'DJOLJ EUXN 5§G RJ WLSV 6WHOO RJ UHQJMºULQJ )HLOVºNLQJ 6Wº\ 7HNQLVNH GDWD ,QIRUPDVMRQ IRU WHVWLQVWLWXWWHU .81'(6777( 2* 6(59,&( %UXN DOOWLG RULJLQDOH UHVHUYHGHOHU 1§U GX NRQWDNWHU Y§UW DXWRULVHUWH VHUYLFHVHQWHU P§ GX VºUJH IRU DW GX KDU IºOJHQGH RSSO\VQLQJHU WLOJMHQJHOLJ 0RGHOO VHULHQXPPHU ,QIRUPDVMRQHQ ILQQHU GX S§ W\SHVNLOWHW $GYDUVHO )RUVLNWLJ ದ 6LNNHUKHWVLQIRUPDVMRQ *HQHUHOO LQ
ವ ವ ವ ವ ವ 'HWWH SURGXNWHW NDQ EUXNHV DY SHUVRQHU PHG VY¨UW RPIDWWHQGH RJ NRPSOHNVH IXQNVMRQVQHGVHWWHOVHU IRUXWVDWW DW GH KDU I§WW ULNWLJ RSSO¨ULQJ %DUQ \QJUH HQQ §U P§ KROGHV S§ DYVWDQG IUD SURGXNWHW PHG PLQGUH GH HU XQGHU WLOV\Q WLO HQKYHU WLG ,NNH OD EDUQ OHNH PHG SURGXNWHW 5HQJMºULQJ RJ YHGOLNHKROG DY SURGXNWHW VNDO LNNH XWIºUHV DY EDUQ 2SSEHYDU DOO HPEDOODVMH XWLOJMHQJHOLJ IRU EDUQ RJ NDVW GHQ S§ ULNWLJ P§WH *HQHUHOO VLNNHUKHW ವ ವ ವ ವ ವ ವ ವ ವ 'HWWH SURGXNWHW HU PHQW § EUXNHV L KXVKROG
ವ ವ ವ RSSYDVNPLGOHU VNXUHVYDPSHU OºVHPLGOHU HOOHU PHWDOOJMHQVWDQGHU 1§U NMºOHVNDSHW EOLU VW§HQGH WRPW L HQ OHQJUH SHULRGH EºU GX VO§ GHW DY DYULPH GHW UHQJMºUH GHW WºUNH GHW RJ OD GºUHQ EOL VW§HQGH RSSH VOLN DW GHW LNNH GDQQHV PXJJ L SURGXNWHW 2SSEHYDU LNNH HNVSORVLYH VWRIIHU VRP DHURVROEHKROGHUH PHG EUHQQEDUW GULYVWRII L GHWWH SURGXNWHW +YLV VWUºPNDEHOHQ EOLU VNDGHW P§ GHQ VNLIWHV DY SURGXVHQWHQ DXWRULVHUW VHUYLFHVHQWHU HOOHU DQQHQ NYDOLILVHUW SHUVRQ IRU § XQQJ§ ULVLNR 6,..
ವ ,NNH VHWW VWºSVHOHW L VWLNNRQWDNWHQ IºU PRQWHULQJHQ HU IXOOIºUW 3§VH DW GHW HU WLOJDQJ WLO VWLNNRQWDNWHQ HWWHU PRQWHULQJHQ ವ ,NNH WUHNN L NDEHOHQ IRU § NREOH IUD SURGXNWHW 7UHNN DOOWLG L VHOYH VWºSVHOHW %UXN $'9$56(/ )DUH IRU VNDGH EUDQQVNDGHU HOHNWULVN VWºW HOOHU EUDQQ $SSDUDWHW LQQHKROGHU EUHQQEDUH JDVVHU LVREXWDQ 5 D QDWXUJDVV PHG OLWHQ LQQYLUNQLQJ S§ PLOMºHW 9¨U IRUVLNWLJ V§ GX LNNH IRU§UVDNHU VNDGH S§ NMºOHPLGGHONUHWVHQ VRP LQQHKROGHU LVREXWDQ ವ 3URGXNWHWV VSHVLILNDVMRQHU P§ LNN
UHSDUDWºUHU RJ DW LNNH DOOH UHVHUYHGHOHU HU UHOHYDQWH IRU DOOH PRGHOOHU ವ 'ºUSDNQLQJHU YLO Y¨UH WLOJMHQJHOLJH L §U HWWHU DW PRGHOOHQ HU DYYLNOHW $YIDOOVEHKDQGOLQJ $'9$56(/ )DUH IRU VNDGH RJ NYHOQLQJ ವ .REOH SURGXNWHW IUD VWUºPPHQ ವ .XWW DY VWUºPNDEHOHQ RJ NDVW GHQ ವ )MHUQ GºUHQ IRU § IRUKLQGUH DW EDUQ RJ G\U EOLU VWHQJW LQQH L SURGXNWHW ವ .MºOHPLGGHONUHWVHQ RJ LVRODVMRQVPDWHULDOHW WLO GHWWH SURGXNWHW HU R]RQ YHQQOLJ ವ ,VRODVMRQVVNXPPHW LQQHKROGHU EUHQQEDUH JDVVHU .
D3 D1 0§O W1 90 D2 ° A W2 B H1 W3 8WYHQGLJH GLPHQVMRQHU { 3ODVV VRP NUHYHV YHG EUXN t + PP : PP ' PP { Kº\GHQ EUHGGHQ RJ G\EGHQ S§ SURGXNWHW XWHQ K§QGWDN RJ IºWWHU 3ODVV VRP NUHYHV YHG EUXN t + $ % PP : PP ' PP $ PP % PP t Kº\GHQ EUHGGHQ RJ G\EGHQ S§ SURGXNWHW LQNOXGHUW K§QGWDNHW SOXVV SODVVHQ VRP HU QºGYHQGLJ IRU IUL VLUNXODVMRQ DY NMºOHOXIW 7RWDO SODVV VRP NUHYHV YHG EUXN u + $ % PP : PP ' PP u
HU QºGYHQGLJ IRU § §SQH GºUHQ WLO PLQVWH YLQNHO VRP JMºU GHW PXOLJ § IMHUQH DOW LQWHUQW XWVW\U 6WHG )RU § VLNUH DW SURGXNWHW IXQJHUHU RSWLPDOW EºU GX LNNH PRQWHUH SURGXNWHW L Q¨UKHWHQ DY YDUPHNLOGHU VWHNHRYQ NRPI\UHU UDGLDWRUHU NRPI\UHU HOOHU NRNHSODWHU HOOHU S§ HW VWHG PHG GLUHNWH VROO\V 3DVV S§ DW OXIWHQ NDQ VLUNXOHUH IULWW UXQGW EDNVLGHQ DY NDELQHWWHW 3URGXNWHW VNDO PRQWHUHV L HQ WºUU JRGW YHQWLOHUW LQQHQGºUV SRVLVMRQ 'HWWH SURGXNWHW HU EHUHJQHW WLO EUXN YHG RPJLYHOVHVWHPSHUDWXU IUD r& W
%(7-(1,1*63$1(/ 1 2 %HUºU WHPSHUDWXUUHJXODWRUHQ IUHP WLO ºQVNHW WHPSHUDWXU HU YDOJW 'HQ LQQVWLOWH WHPSHUDWXUHQ Q§V LQQHQ WLPHU (WWHU VWUºPEUXGG IRUEOLU GHQ LQQVWLOWH WHPSHUDWXUHQ ODJUHW )DVW)UHH]H IXQNVMRQ 4 3 7HPSHUDWXULQGLNDWRU /(' )DVW)UHH]H LQGLNDWRU )DVW)UHH]H NQDSS 7HUPRVWDWEU\WHU 3 $9 NQDSS 6OLN VO§U GX S§ SURGXNWHW 6HWW VWºSVHOHW LQQ L VWUºPXWWDNHW %HUºU NQDSSHQ IRU WHPSHUDWXUUHJXODWRUHQ KYLV DOOH /(' LQGLNDWRUHU HU DY 6O§ DY %HUºU NQDSSHQ IRU WHPSHUDWXU
'$*/,* %58. 6OLN SODVVHUHU GX GºUK\OOHQH *UºQQVDNVVNXIIHU 'ºUK\OOHQH NDQ VHWWHV L IRUVNMHOOLJH Kº\GHU IRU § LPºWHNRPPH PDWSDNQLQJHU DY IRUVNMHOOLJH VWºUUHOVHU 'HW HU VSHVLHOOH VNXIIHU L GHQ QHGHUVWH GHOHQ DY SURGXNWHW VRP HU HJQHW IRU RSSEHYDULQJ DY IUXNW RJ JUºQQVDNHU 'UD K\OOHQ JUDGYLV RSS WLO GHQ OºVQHU )O\WW GHQ HWWHU EHKRY 7HPSHUDWXULQGLNDWRU )RU ULNWLJ RSSEHYDULQJ DY PDW HU NMºOHVNDSHW XWVW\UW PHG WHPSHUDWXULQGLNDWRU 6\PEROHW S§ VLGHYHJJHQ DY SURGXNWHW YLVHU GHW NDOGHVWH RPU§GHW L
, GHQQH WLOVWDQGHQ NDQ WHPSHUDWXUHQ LQQH L NMºOHVNDSHW HQGUH VHJ OLWW 2SSEHYDULQJ DY IURVVHQ PDW 1§U GX VO§U S§ DSSDUDWHW IRU IºUVWH JDQJ HOOHU HWWHU HQ SHULRGH GHU GHQ LNNH KDU VW§WW S§ P§ GX OD GHQ VW§ S§ L PLQVW WLPHU PHG )DVW)UHH]H IXQNVMRQHQ VO§WW S§ )U\VHVNXIIHQH VºUJHU IRU DW GX UDVNW RJ HQNHOW ILQQHU GHW GX OHWHU HWWHU )MHUQ DOOH VNXIIHQH KYLV GX VNDO RSSEHYDUH VWºUUH PHQJGHU PDWYDUHU RJ SODVVHU PDWHQ S§ K\OOHQH 2SSEHYDU PDWHQ PLQVW PP IUD GºUHQ )256,.
ವ 'HW DQEHIDOHV § VHWWH HWLNHWWHU RJ GDWRHU S§ DOO GHQ IURVQH PDWHQ 'HWWH YLO JMºUH GHW OHWWHUH § LGHQWLILVHUH PDWYDUHU RJ WLO § YLWH Q§U GH VNDO EUXNHV IºU GH IRUGHUYHU ವ 0DWHQ VNDO Y¨UH IHUVN Q§U GHQ IU\VHV IRU § EHYDUH JRG NYDOLWHW 6¨UOLJ IUXNW RJ JUºQQVDNHU EºU IU\VHV HWWHU KºVWLQJ IRU § EHYDUH DOOH Q¨ULQJVVWRIIHQH GHUHV ವ )U\V LNNH IODVNHU HOOHU ERNVHU PHG Y¨VNHU VSHVLHOW GULNNH VRP LQQHKROGHU NDUERQGLRNVLG ದ GH NDQ HNVSORGHUH XQGHU IU\VLQJ ವ ,NNH VHWW YDUP PDW LQQ L IU\VHURPPHW $YNMºO GHQ Y
0DWYDUHW\SH +ROGEDUKHW P§QH഻ GHU 6PºU 0\NRVW I HNV PR]]DUHOOD +DUG RVW I HNV SDUPHVDQ FKHGGDU 6MºPDW )HW ILVN I HNV ODNV PDNUHOO 0DJHU ILVN I HNV WRUVN IO\QGUH 5HNHU 0XVOLQJHU RJ VNMHOO XWHQ VNDOO .RNW ILVN .MºWW )M¨UNUH 6WRUIHNMºWW 6YLQHNMºWW /DPPHNMºWW 3ºOVH 6NLQNH 5HVWHU PHG NMºWW 7LSV WLO NMºOLQJ DY IHUVNH PDWYDUHU ವ (Q JRG WHPSHUDWXULQQVWLOOLQJ VRP VLNUHU NRQVHUYHULQJ DY IHUVN PDW HU HQ WHPSHUDWXU XQGHU HOOHU OLN r& +º\HUH WHPSHUDWXU
67(// 2* 5(1*-5,1* $'9$56(/ 6H HWWHU L 6LNNHUKHWVNDSLWOHQH ,QQYHQGLJ UHQJMºULQJ )ºU GX WDU SURGXNWHW L EUXN P§ GX YDVNH LQQVLGHQ VDPW DOW XWVW\U L OXQNHQW YDQQ WLOVDWW HW Qº\WUDOW UHQJMºULQJVPLGGHO IRU § IMHUQH GHQ W\SLVNH OXNWHQ VRP VLWWHU L IOXQNHQGH Q\H SURGXNWHU +XVN § WºUNH Qº\H )256,.7,* ,NNH EUXN NUDIWLJH YDVNHPLGOHU HOOHU VNXUHSXOYHU NORU HOOHU ROMHEDVHUW YDVNHPLGGHO GD GHWWH YLO VNDGH ILQLVKHQ )256,.
6HWW HQ EROOH PHG YDUPW YDQQ LQQ L IU\VHUHQ IRU § I§ DYULPLQJVSURVHVVHQ WLO § J§ UDVNHUH )MHUQ RJV§ VW\NNHU DY LV VRP OºVQHU IºU DYULPLQJHQ HU IHUGLJ %UXN GHQ PHGIºOJHQGH LVVNUDSHUHQ WLO GHWWH IRUP§OHW 7ºUN LQQVLGHQ DY VNDSHW JUXQGLJ Q§U DYULPLQJHQ HU IHUGLJ %HKROG LVVNUDSHUHQ IRU IUHPWLGLJ EUXN 6O§ S§ SURGXNWHW RJ OXNN GºUHQ 6WLOO WHUPRVWDWEU\WHUHQ S§ PDNVLPDO NMºOLQJ RJ OD SURGXNWHW J§ L PLQVW WUH WLPHU PHG GHQQH LQQVWLOOLQJHQ 9HQW WLO GHQQH WLGHQ HU IRUEL IºU GX OHJJHU PDWHQ WLOED
3UREOHP 0XOLJ §UVDN /ºVQLQJ 5RPWHPSHUDWXUHQ HU IRU Kº\ 6H NDSLWOHW m0RQWHULQJ} 0DWYDUHQH VRP EOH ODJW LQQ YDU IRU YDUPH /D PDWYDUHU DYNMºOH VHJ WLO URPWHPSHUDWXU IºU GX OHJJHU GHP LQQ 'ºUHQ HU LNNH VNLNNHOLJ VWHQJW 5HIHUHU WLO DYVQLWWHW m6WHQJ GºUHQ} )DVW)UHH]H IXQNVMRQHQ HU VO§WW S§ 5HIHUHU WLO DYVQLWWHW m)DVWಣ )UHH]H IXQNVMRQ} .RPSUHVVRUHQ VWDUWHU LNNH PHG HQ JDQJ HWWHU DW GX KDU WU\NNHW S§ m)DVW)UHH]H} HOಣ OHU HWWHU DW WHPSHUDWXUHQ HU HQGUHW .
3UREOHP 0XOLJ §UVDN /ºVQLQJ 'HW HU IRU P\H NRQGHQVHUW YDQQ S§ EDNYHJJHQ L NMºOHಣ VNDSHW 'X §SQHU GºUHQ IRU RIWH SQH GºUHQ NXQ Q§U GHW HU QºGYHQGLJ 'ºUHQ EOH LNNH VWHQJW S§ ULNಣ WLJ P§WH 3§VH DW GºUHQ HU RUGHQWOLJ VWHQJW /DJUHW PDW YDU LNNH LQQSDNಣ NHW LQQ 3DNN LQQ PDW L HJQHW HPEDOಣ ODVMH IºU GX OHJJHU GHQ L DSಣ SDUDWHW 'HW UHQQHU YDQQ LQQH L NMºOHಣ VNDSHW 0DWYDUHU IRUKLQGUHU DW YDQಣ QHW UHQQHU LQQ L YDQQRSSಣ VDPOLQJVEHKROGHUHQ 6ºUJ IRU DW PDWYDUHQH LNNH EHUºUHU EDNYHJJHQ
3UREOHP 0XOLJ §UVDN /ºVQLQJ 1RHQ DY RYHUIODWHQH L NMºOHಣ VNDSHW NDQ WLO WLGHU Y¨UH YDUಣ PHUH 'HWWH HU QRUPDOW /(' ODPSHQH IRU WHPSHUDWXಣ ULQQVWLOOLQJHU EOLQNHU VDPWLಣ GLJ 'HW KDU RSSVW§WW HQ IHLO L WHPSHUDWXUP§OLQJHQ .RQWDNW GHW DXWRULVHUWH VHUಣ YLFH VHQWHUHW .MºOHV\VWHPHW IRUWVHWWHU § KROGH PDWYDUHQH NDOGH PHQ GHW YLO LNNH Y¨UH PXOLJ § MXVWHUH WHPSHUDWXಣ UHQ 'HUVRP U§GHW LNNH JLU UHVXOWDWHU WD NRQWDNW PHG Q¨UPHVWH DXWRULVHUWH VHUYLFHVHQWHU 6NLIWH O\VS¨UH 3URGXNWHW HU XWVW\UW PHG HW
67< SSSRRR! BRRR! CLICK! HISSS! BLUBB! 7(.1,6.( '$7$ 7HNQLVNH GDWD ILQQHU GX S§ W\SHVNLOWHW S§ LQQVLGHQ DY DSSDUDWHW RJ S§ HQHUJLHWLNHWWHQ 45 NRGHQ S§ HQHUJLHWLNHWWHQ VRP IXOJWH PHG DSSDUDWHW JLU HQ QHWWNREOLQJ WLO LQIRUPDVMRQHQ VRP HU UHODWHUW WLO \WHOVHQ DY GHWWH DSSDUDWHW L (8 (35(/ GDWDEDVHQ 2SSEHYDU HQHUJLHWLNHWWHQ NXQ IRU KHQYLVQLQJ PHG GHQQH EUXNHUK§QGERNHQ VDPW DOOH DQGUH GRNXPHQWHU VRP IXOJWH PHG GHWWH SURGXNWHW 'HW HU RJV§ PXOLJ § ILQQH GHQ VDPPH LQIRUPDVMRQHQ L (35(/ PHG NREOLQJHQ K
%(6.<77(/6( $9 0,/-(7 5HVLUNXOHU PDWHULDOHU VRP HU PHUNHW PHG V\PEROHW /HJJ HPEDOODVMHQ L ULNWLJH EHKROGHUH IRU § UHVLUNXOHUH GHW %LGUDU WLO § EHVN\WWH PLOMºHW PHQQHVNHUV KHOVH RJ IRU § UHVLUNXOHUH DYIDOO DY HOHNWULVNH RJ HOHNWURQLVNH SURGXNWHU ,NNH NDVW SURGXNWHU VRP HU PHUNHW PHG V\PEROHW VDPPHQ PHG KXVKROGQLQJVDYIDOOHW 3URGXNWHW NDQ OHYHUHV GHU KYRU WLOVYDUHQGH SURGXNW VHOJHV HOOHU S§ PLOMºVWDVMRQHQ L NRPPXQHQ .RQWDNW NRPPXQHQ IRU Q¨UPHUH RSSO\VQLQJHU
