Technical Specifications

REESE'S PeanutButterTemptationsRecipe
PrepTime:20Minutes
SkillLevel:Beginner
Recipe Rating
Getoutyourmuffintinandbakethebestpeanutbuttercookiesyou've
evertasted. Eachonecontainsachocolatepeanutbuttercupinside.
Ingredients
• About40 REESE'S Peanut Butter CupsMiniaturesor12(0.75oz.each) REESE'S PeanutButter Cups,
quartered
• 1/2cup (1stick)butterormargarine,softened
• 1/2cupgranulatedsugar
• 1/2cuppackedlightbrownsugar
• 1/2cup REESE'S Creamy Peanut Butter
• 1egg
• 1/2 teaspoonvanillaextract
• 1-1/2cupsall-purposeflour
• 3/4 teaspoonbakingsoda
• 1/2 teaspoonsalt
Directions
• 1. Heatoven to375°F. Removewrappers fromcandies.Linesmallmuffincups (1-3/4inchesindiameter)
withpaperbakecups.
•
• 2. Beatbutter,brownsugar,granulatedsugar,peanutbutter,eggandvanillauntillightandfluffyinlarge
bowl. Stir together flour,bakingsodaandsalt;add tobuttermixture,beatinguntilwellblended. Shape
doughinto1-inchballs;placeoneineachpreparedmuffincup. Donotflatten.
•
• 3. Bake10 to12minutesuntilpuffedandlightlybrowned; remove fromoven. Immediatelypresspeanut
buttercuporpieceontoeachcookie. Coolcompletelyinmuffinpan. About3-1/2dozencookies.