Specifications

USB Key Cage Match
2GB pocket-size storage solutions face off
I
n addition to reaching capacities up to 2GB
and beyond, today’s USB keys have splintered
into two factions: flash-based and hard drive-
based units. To see which technology rules, we
sent three new “keys” to the mini-Gitmo we call
the Maximum PC Lab. Our testing regimen con-
sisted of a 1GB read/write test using files ranging
in size from a lowly 2Kb to 300MB. With stop-
watch in hand, we put them to the test.
—MICHAEL COLEMAN
M-Systems: Smart DiskOnKey
M-Systems pretty much invented the USB key and
in the process set a high standard for the category.
This all-new flash-based 2GB version mostly lives
up to the company’s reputation.
During testing, the key performed reliably
and worked in every USB port it was plugged
into. It posted the fastest read times of the keys
reviewed here and came in second, by a hair, in
write times. Overall, its perfor-
mance feels snappy and
responsive. It is recognized instantly and trans-
fers files quickly.
As with all M-Systems keys, the Smart
DiskOnKey ships with proprietary security software
that lets you password protect a portion of the key.
As an added convenience, you’re given the option to
designate your own PC as a “no password zone.”
The only real complaint we have with this key is
its formfactor, which looks and feels a bit shoddy.
Every other M-Systems key we’ve reviewed has
been sleek and stylish, whereas this one looks
blocky and generic.
Verbatim Store ‘n’ Go
The Store ‘n’ Go is the interloper in this roundup,
using a teeny 2.2GB hard drive instead of flash
memory as its storage medium. Because of the hard
drive’s much larger footprint, the Store ‘n’ Go is big-
ger in size than the flash-based units. Still, it fits in
your pocket, and is the only drive in the roundup to
include a neoprene carrying case. What’s more, it
connects to the PC via a two-inch cable that tucks
back into the drive’s body when not in use.
Sadly, the hard drive’s transfer times were much
slower than those posted by the flash-based drives. It
puttered to dead last in both our read and write tests.
To its benefit, the Store ‘n’ Go is the least
expensive of the bunch—almost half the price of
M-Systems’ key. But we think it’s worth it to pay a bit
more for a drive that’s both faster and more portable.
Memorex TravelDrive
Memorex’s flash-based USB drive has exactly what
most people look for in a USB key drive: a small
footprint and great performance. During testing, this
USB 2.0/1.1 drive reported the fastest write times
of the bunch, and read speeds that were just a tick
slower than those of M-Systems’ offering.
We have nothing but praise for the TravelDrive’s
rubberized casing. It feels solid in spite of its min-
iature size, and has a sporty, rugged look that’s just
plain cool. Unfortunately, the small plastic loop that
makes the drive portable on a key chain broke off
of our review unit—so carrying the drive like a key
is not advisable. The loops on the other drives were
much sturdier by comparison.
Finally, the drive is the only one in this roundup
to include a physical “read-only” switch that you
can toggle to prevent the contents of the drive
from being mistakenly erased. It’s a handy
addition to a solid-performing drive.
Password protection for files, zippy transfers.
SNOOPY DANCE
ODIE DROOL
Design is unappealing, case scratches easily.
$470, www.diskonkey.com
9
MAXIMUMPC
VERDICT
Easy connection via small cord.
MOBY DICK
FREE WILLY
Very slow transfer rates.
$250, www.verbatim.com
6
MAXIMUMPC
VERDICT
write times. Overall, its perfor-
mance feels snappy and
Though we’re
not fond of this drive’s
“cheese wedge” formfactor,
its performance is excellent.
Store ‘n’ Slow
would be a more
appropriate name
for this hard drive-
based USB drive.
to include a physical “read-only” switch that you
can toggle to prevent the contents of the drive
from being mistakenly erased. It’s a handy
addition to a solid-performing drive.
The Traveldrive includes a
handy “read only” switch
you can toggle to lock
down the drive’s contents
before loaning it to a
doofus.
Highly portable, excellent performance.
PETA
KFC
No encryption software, and keychain loop is fragile.
$300, www.memorex.com
8
MAXIMUMPC
VERDICT